A virtualisation platform is the foundation of a private cloud: the company’s servers, databases and applications run on it. Since Broadcom changed VMware licensing, many companies are reconsidering their platform. We compare three common options — VMware vSphere with the ESXi hypervisor, Microsoft Hyper-V and Proxmox VE — and look at how to choose.
What a hypervisor is
A hypervisor is software that creates virtual machines and shares a physical server’s resources between them: processor, memory, disks, network. Each virtual machine works like a separate computer with its own operating system.
There are two types of hypervisor:
- Type 1 is installed directly on the server and manages the hardware itself. These are the hypervisors used for server virtualisation and private clouds — including all three platforms in this article.
- Type 2 runs on top of an ordinary operating system — for example, on a developer’s laptop for testing. It is not used for production servers.
The hypervisor itself is only the foundation. What turns it into a private cloud is cluster management, high availability, storage, backup and monitoring — and that is where the platforms differ most.
What changed at VMware
- Subscription only. VMware announced the end of availability of perpetual licences and Support and Subscription (SnS) renewals: its main offers became VMware Cloud Foundation and VMware vSphere Foundation, sold only as subscriptions.
- Existing perpetual licences keep working. According to the Broadcom knowledge base, SnS expiry does not revoke the right to use the software, but downloading patches, security updates and new versions is limited to accounts with active support.
- vSphere 8 support timeline. According to the Broadcom knowledge base, general support for vSphere 8 (ESXi, vCenter, vSAN) ends on 11 October 2027 — a natural horizon for the platform decision.
For perpetual licence holders this means a choice: move to a subscription, stay on the current version for a while and manage the security risks, or plan a move to another platform.
The three platforms at a glance
| VMware vSphere (ESXi) | Microsoft Hyper-V | Proxmox VE | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Licence model | subscription (VMware Cloud Foundation, vSphere Foundation) | a Windows Server role; terms depend on the edition (Standard or Datacenter) | open source; a paid per-CPU-socket subscription gives Enterprise Repository access and technical support |
| Cluster and high availability | yes | Failover Clustering in both Standard and Datacenter | high-availability clusters |
| Software-defined storage | vSAN | Storage Spaces Direct — Datacenter only | Ceph, ZFS |
| Veeam backup | yes | yes | yes, from Veeam Backup & Replication 12.2 for Proxmox VE 8.2 and later |
| Suits | companies with VMware expertise and investment, ready for a subscription | Windows-based infrastructures that already have Windows Server licences | teams ready for Linux administration and an open platform |
The last row is our practical view, not a rule: the final choice depends on your workloads and your team.
How to choose: criteria
- Total cost over several years: licences or subscription, support, hardware, admin time, renewal terms.
- Team expertise. Who will run the platform — and whether they know enough to restore it at night during an outage.
- Application compatibility. Whether the vendor of your database, accounting or ERP system supports running on the chosen platform.
- High availability and storage. How many nodes, which storage — external or software-defined, what network requirements.
- Backup and monitoring. Whether your backup and monitoring tools support the platform. For example, Veeam Backup & Replication 12.2 added Proxmox VE support with limitations worth checking before you choose.
- Vendor support. Response times, language, availability of security updates.
- Regulation. If an external provider delivers the platform as a cloud service, financial institutions must take NBU Resolution No. 99 into account — see “NBU Resolution 99: cloud for banks and fintech”.
If you decide to migrate
Moving between hypervisors is a migration and deserves the same care as a move to the cloud:
- Inventory of virtual machines, dependencies, guest OS and application licences.
- A pilot on non-critical machines: disk conversion, replacing guest drivers and agents, performance checks.
- Backups before every stage, with tested restores — see “3-2-1 backup rule: protecting business data”.
- Waves and maintenance windows with a rollback plan.
- Updated documentation and monitoring after the move.
The general migration plan is in “Cloud migration: a step-by-step plan for business”: most steps are the same for moving between virtualisation platforms.
Frequently asked questions
Is it worth moving if VMware works? It depends on your support status. Without active support there is no access to patches and security updates, and for the hypervisor your whole infrastructure runs on, that is a serious risk. Compare the cost of a multi-year subscription with the cost of migrating to and running another platform — sometimes staying is cheaper, sometimes not.
Is Proxmox VE free? The platform is open source. A paid subscription, priced per CPU socket, gives access to the Enterprise Repository and the vendor’s technical support. For production systems, budget for it or have enough in-house expertise to support it yourself.
Can platforms be combined? Yes, for example while moving workloads gradually. But every additional platform means separate skills, updates, backup and monitoring, so keep a long-term mixed environment only for a clear reason.
Checklist
- The licence and support status of the current platform is known
- The total cost of each option over several years is calculated
- Key applications are confirmed compatible with the chosen platform
- Cluster, storage and network architecture is defined
- Backup and monitoring tools support the platform
- The team has the expertise or support to run it
- A pilot is done, a migration plan with rollback exists
- Backups are tested before every stage
How Bereg-IT can help
We design, deploy and support private clouds: we survey your servers and workloads, design the platform, backup and monitoring, and move services to an agreed plan. Among other platforms we work with VMware and Microsoft Hyper-V, and we will help compare other options against your requirements. If some workloads should move to a public cloud, we will also consider a hybrid setup.
The first consultation is free. Send a request and an IT engineer will get in touch.
Sources
- VMware Cloud Foundation Blog, VMware End Of Availability of Perpetual Licensing and SaaS Services (22.01.2024): https://blogs.vmware.com/cloud-foundation/2024/01/22/vmware-end-of-availability-of-perpetual-licensing-and-saas-services/
- Broadcom Knowledge Base, Perpetual License Functionality After Support and Subscription (SnS) Expiration: https://knowledge.broadcom.com/external/article/429208/perpetual-license-functionality-after-su.html
- Microsoft Learn, Comparison of Windows Server editions: https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-server/get-started/editions-comparison
- Proxmox, Proxmox Virtual Environment — overview and subscriptions: https://www.proxmox.com/en/products/proxmox-virtual-environment/overview, https://www.proxmox.com/en/products/proxmox-virtual-environment/pricing
- Veeam, Veeam Backup & Replication 12.2 Release Notes — Proxmox VE support: https://helpcenter.veeam.com/rn/veeam_backup_12_2_release_notes.html
- Broadcom Knowledge Base, End of General Support for vSphere 8.0: https://knowledge.broadcom.com/external/article/459135/end-of-general-support-for-vsphere-80.html